spacemacs/layers/+lang/haskell/README.org

#+TITLE: Haskell layer

#+TAGS: general|layer|programming|pure

[[file:img/haskell.png]]

* Table of Contents                     :TOC_5_gh:noexport:
- [[#description][Description]]
  - [[#features][Features:]]
- [[#quick-start-and-how-to-use-this-readme][Quick start (and how to use this README)]]
- [[#install][Install]]
  - [[#layer][Layer]]
  - [[#dependencies][Dependencies]]
  - [[#setup-path][Setup PATH]]
- [[#configuration][Configuration]]
  - [[#choosing-a-backend][Choosing a backend]]
    - [[#dante][=dante=]]
    - [[#lsp][=lsp=]]
      - [[#hie][=hie=]]
      - [[#hls][=hls=]]
  - [[#optional-extras][Optional extras]]
    - [[#structured-haskell-mode][structured-haskell-mode]]
    - [[#hindent][hindent]]
- [[#key-bindings][Key bindings]]
  - [[#documentation][Documentation]]
  - [[#debug][Debug]]
  - [[#debug-buffer][Debug Buffer]]
  - [[#repl][REPL]]
  - [[#cabal-commands][Cabal commands]]
  - [[#cabal-files][Cabal files]]
  - [[#refactor][Refactor]]
- [[#syntax-checking][Syntax checking]]
  - [[#flycheck][Flycheck]]
  - [[#hlint][HLint]]
- [[#faq][FAQ]]
  - [[#dante-reports-missinghidden-imports-for-test-files][Dante reports missing/hidden imports for test files]]
  - [[#the-repl-doesnt-work][The REPL doesn't work]]
  - [[#the-repl-is-stuck][The REPL is stuck]]
  - [[#indentation-doesnt-reset-when-pressing-return-after-an-empty-line][Indentation doesn't reset when pressing return after an empty line]]
  - [[#flycheck-displays-hlint-warnings-but-not-errors][Flycheck displays HLint warnings but not errors]]
  - [[#hlint-fails-with-parse-error][HLint fails with parse error]]
  - [[#i-can-see-highlighted-errors-but-they-dont-appear-in-the-error-list][I can see highlighted errors but they don't appear in the error list]]
  - [[#flycheck-doesnt-work][Flycheck doesn't work]]
  - [[#flycheck-doesnt-work-with-stack][Flycheck doesn't work with =stack=]]
    - [[#the-stack-build-directory-is-wrong][The =stack= build directory is wrong]]
    - [[#the-project-root-directory-is-not-set-properly][The Project root directory is not set properly]]
  - [[#haskell-mode-commands-dont-work][haskell-mode commands don't work]]

* Description
This layer adds support for the [[https://www.haskell.org/][Haskell]] language.

** Features:
- syntax highlighting for [[https://github.com/haskell/haskell-mode][haskell source]], [[https://github.com/haskell/haskell-mode][cabal files]], [[https://github.com/bgamari/cmm-mode][C-- source]]
- auto-completion and syntax-checking with one of the selected backends (=dante= or =lsp=).

* Quick start (and how to use this README)
- Follow instructions in *Install* section to correctly install the layer.
- Ensure that you have =auto-completion= and =syntax-checking= layers enabled.
- Set backend to =dante= (check *Configuration* section for details). =dante= is default already, but if =lsp= layer is enabled, you will have to set it explicitly.
- You are ready to go! Open any Haskell project and enjoy syntax-checking, auto-completion and more.

After that, check the rest of the README to:
- Learn about more powerful (but more complicated to set up) backend: =lsp= with =hie= / =hls=: Check *Configuration* -> *lsp*.
- Learn about all the functionalities and key bindings: Check *Key bindings* and *Configuration* -> *Optional extras*.
- Learn about the details of how syntax-checking works and how it can be tweaked: Check *Syntax checking*.
- Find solutions to common problems in FAQ: Check *FAQ*.

* Install
** Layer
To use this configuration layer, add it to your =~/.spacemacs=. You will need to
add =haskell= to the existing =dotspacemacs-configuration-layers= list in this
file.

** Dependencies
This layer requires some [[https://www.haskell.org/cabal/][cabal]] packages:
- =apply-refact= (required by =hlint-refactor=)
- =hlint= (required by =hlint-refactor=)
- =stylish-haskell= (optional for =haskell-mode=)
- =hasktags= (optional)
- =hoogle= (optional for =haskell-mode= and =helm-hoogle=)

To install them, use the following command (or the =stack= equivalent):

#+BEGIN_SRC sh
  $ cabal install apply-refact hlint stylish-haskell hasktags hoogle
#+END_SRC

** Setup PATH
First of all, make sure that your =$PATH= contains the installation path for
Haskell tools like =ghc=, =ghci= etc. It depends on how you have installed
=ghc=, but you can always check it by running =which ghc= in your terminal.
=Stack= users should only add the installation path of =stack= itself. Usually
it's =~/.local/bin=.

Then make sure that your =$PATH= contains the installation path for the =cabal=
packages. If you are using =cabal= it should be =~/.cabal/bin= or
=~/Library/Haskell/bin= (for 'Haskell for Mac' users). If you are using =stack=
then it should be =~/.local/bin=.

For more information about setting up =$PATH=, check out the corresponding section in
the FAQ (~SPC h SPC $PATH RET~).

* Configuration
** Choosing a backend
Language backend is the core component of a language layer - it has the responsibility of compiling/parsing the actual code and reporting errors, warnings, suggesting fixes, auto-completions and more.

To get the most out of the language backend, you will want to ensure that you have =auto-completion= and =syntax-checking= layers enabled.

Then, to choose a haskell backend, set the haskell layer variable =haskell-completion-backend=:

#+BEGIN_SRC emacs-lisp
  (haskell :variables haskell-completion-backend 'dante)
#+END_SRC

Supported values for =haskell-completion-backend= are =dante= and =lsp=.

If you don't specify any value for =haskell-completion-backend=,
=dante= will be used as default backend, unless the layer =lsp= is enabled,
in which case =lsp= is used as default backend.

Backend can be chosen on a per project basis using directory local variables
(files named =.dir-locals.el= at the root of a project). An example of =.dir-locals.el= to use the
=lsp= backend:

#+BEGIN_SRC elisp
  ;;; Directory Local Variables
  ;;; For more information see (info "(emacs) Directory Variables")

  ((haskell-mode (haskell-completion-backend . lsp)))
#+END_SRC

*Note:* you can easily add a directory local variable with ~SPC f v d~.

There are two backends available: =dante= and =lsp=.

=dante= is lightweight, requires no setup and works out of the box in most cases, which is why it is also a default backend.

=lsp= (=hie= or =hls=) is a more ambitious, heavy-weight, cutting-edge backend that is however still somewhat rough on the edges and requires some additional setup.

*** =dante=
[[https://github.com/jyp/dante][Dante]] is a lightweight backend which delegates most of its work directly to GHCi.

It brings features like syntax checking, auto completion, hlint suggestions, automatic error fixing, info at point, definition and use sites.

=dante= works for =cabal=, =nix=, =sytx=, and =stack= users and requires no additional setup.

*** =lsp=
[[https://microsoft.github.io/language-server-protocol][Language Server Protocol]] is a standard for implementing language backends.

In Haskell layer, you can use a backend that implements Language Server Protocol for Haskell by specifying =lsp= as backend
and then installing concrete backend implementation, of which there are two available at the moment: =hie= and =hls=.

Enabling the =lsp= backend requires the =lsp= layer to be enabled, and provides access to
all the additional =lsp-mode= key bindings.

**** =hie=
[[https://github.com/haskell/haskell-ide-engine][Haskell Ide Engine]] (=hie=) aims to be the universal interface to a growing number of Haskell tools,
providing a fully-featured Language Server Protocol server for editors and IDEs that require Haskell-specific functionality.

This is where most of the Haskell community effort is (was - check =hls=) being focused regarding building Haskell IDE / language backend.

=hie= is best installed by building it locally as it requires that the same GHC version has been used to
compile your code as has been used for =hie=.

To install it please refer to the official installation instructions [[https://github.com/haskell/haskell-ide-engine#installation][here]].

NOTE: =hie= is being superseded by =hls=, which is still in early development though.

**** =hls=
[[https://github.com/haskell/haskell-language-server][Haskell Language Server]] (=hls=) is integration point for ghcide and =hie=. One IDE to rule them all.

=hls= is meant to supersede =hie= and is therefore the cutting-edge and most ambitious implementation of Haskell language backend.
However, it is still in early stages of development.

Check their docs for installation details and how to use it with emacs/spacemacs.

** Optional extras
The Haskell layer supports some extra features, which can be enabled through the
layer variables.

*** structured-haskell-mode
Currently there is no support for [[https://github.com/chrisdone/structured-haskell-mode][structured-haskell-mode]], since it doesn't play
very well with non-emacs editing styles ([[https://github.com/chrisdone/structured-haskell-mode/issues/81][structured-haskell-mode/#81]]). Emacs
editing style users can easily enable it by adding =structured-haskell-mode= to
the list of =dotspacemacs-additional-packages= in your =.spacemacs= file. For
more installation instructions, please refer to the official documentation at
the [[https://github.com/chrisdone/structured-haskell-mode#features][structured-haskell-mode]] page. In case you are a non-emacs editing style user
and still want to use =structured-haskell-mode= - use it at your own risk.

Any contributions that will help to solve issues with =structured-haskell-mode=
are warmly welcome!

*** hindent
[[https://github.com/commercialhaskell/hindent][hindent]] is an extensible Haskell pretty printer, which lets you reformat your
code. You need to install the executable with =cabal install hindent= or
=stack install hindent=.

To enable it you have to toggle the variable =haskell-enable-hindent=.

See examples [[https://github.com/commercialhaskell/hindent/blob/master/TESTS.md][here]].

#+BEGIN_SRC emacs-lisp
  (setq-default dotspacemacs-configuration-layers
    '((haskell :variables haskell-enable-hindent t)))
#+END_SRC

* Key bindings
All Haskell specific bindings are prefixed with the major-mode leader ~SPC m~.

Top-level commands are prefixed by ~SPC m~:

| Key binding | Description                                                         |
|-------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------|
| ~SPC m g g~ | go to definition or tag                                             |
| ~SPC m g i~ | cycle the Haskell import lines or return to point (with prefix arg) |
| ~SPC m F~   | format buffer using haskell-stylish                                 |
| ~SPC m f~   | format declaration using hindent (if enabled)                       |

** Documentation
Documentation commands are prefixed by ~SPC m h~

| Key binding | Description                                                                |
|-------------+----------------------------------------------------------------------------|
| ~SPC m h d~ | find or generate Haddock documentation for the identifier under the cursor |
| ~SPC m h f~ | do a helm-hoogle lookup                                                    |
| ~SPC m h h~ | do a Hoogle lookup                                                         |
| ~SPC m h H~ | do a local Hoogle lookup                                                   |
| ~SPC m h i~ | gets information for the identifier under the cursor                       |
| ~SPC m h t~ | gets the type of the identifier under the cursor                           |

** Debug
Debug commands are prefixed by ~SPC m d~:

| Key binding | Description                                |
|-------------+--------------------------------------------|
| ~SPC m d a~ | abandon current process                    |
| ~SPC m d b~ | insert breakpoint at function              |
| ~SPC m d B~ | delete breakpoint                          |
| ~SPC m d c~ | continue current process                   |
| ~SPC m d d~ | start debug process, needs to be run first |
| ~SPC m d n~ | next breakpoint                            |
| ~SPC m d N~ | previous breakpoint                        |
| ~SPC m d p~ | previous breakpoint                        |
| ~SPC m d r~ | refresh process buffer                     |
| ~SPC m d s~ | step into the next function                |
| ~SPC m d t~ | trace the expression                       |

** Debug Buffer

| Key binding | Description                                 |
|-------------+---------------------------------------------|
| ~RET~       | select object at the point                  |
| ~a~         | abandon current computation                 |
| ~b~         | break on function                           |
| ~c~         | continue the current computation            |
| ~d~         | delete object at the point                  |
| ~i~         | step into the next function                 |
| ~r~         | refresh the debugger buffer                 |
| ~s~         | go to next step to inspect bindings         |
| ~S~         | go to previous step to inspect the bindings |
| ~t~         | trace the expression                        |

** REPL
REPL commands are prefixed by ~SPC m s~:

| Key binding | Description                                     |
|-------------+-------------------------------------------------|
| ~SPC m s b~ | load or reload the current buffer into the REPL |
| ~SPC m s c~ | clear the REPL                                  |
| ~SPC m s s~ | show and switch to the REPL                     |
| ~SPC m s S~ | show the REPL without switching to it           |
| ~C-j~       | switch to next history item                     |
| ~C-k~       | switch to previous history item                 |
| ~C-l~       | clear the REPL                                  |

** Cabal commands
Cabal commands are prefixed by ~SPC m c~:

| Key binding | Description                                                |
|-------------+------------------------------------------------------------|
| ~SPC m c a~ | cabal actions                                              |
| ~SPC m c b~ | build the current cabal project, i.e. invoke =cabal build= |
| ~SPC m c c~ | compile the current project, i.e. invoke =ghc=             |
| ~SPC m c v~ | visit the cabal file                                       |

** Cabal files
These commands are available in a cabal file.

| Key binding | Description                                 |
|-------------+---------------------------------------------|
| ~SPC m d~   | add a dependency to the project             |
| ~SPC m b~   | go to benchmark section                     |
| ~SPC m e~   | go to executable section                    |
| ~SPC m t~   | go to test-suite section                    |
| ~SPC m m~   | go to exposed modules                       |
| ~SPC m l~   | go to library section                       |
| ~SPC m n~   | go to next subsection                       |
| ~SPC m p~   | go to previous subsection                   |
| ~SPC m s c~ | clear the REPL                              |
| ~SPC m s s~ | show the REPL without switching to it       |
| ~SPC m s S~ | show and switch to the REPL                 |
| ~SPC m N~   | go to next section                          |
| ~SPC m P~   | go to previous section                      |
| ~SPC m f~   | find or create source-file under the cursor |

** Refactor
Refactor commands are prefixed by ~SPC m r~:

| Key binding | Description                                       |
|-------------+---------------------------------------------------|
| ~SPC m r b~ | apply all HLint suggestions in the current buffer |
| ~SPC m r i~ | reformat imports from anywhere in the buffer      |
| ~SPC m r r~ | apply the HLint suggestion under the cursor       |

Only some of the HLint suggestions can be applied.

* Syntax checking
There are multiple components that can indicate
errors and warnings in the code. Those components are:
- dante (via flycheck)
- hlint (via flycheck)
- lsp (via lsp-ui)

Since some of these components can be active at the same time, it can be tricky to
know which component is displaying which message, especially when they disagree,
or if one isn't working. Only flycheck errors (from ghci and hlint) are displayed in
the error list and can be navigated between, using the standard Spacemacs key
bindings (under ~SPC e~) even though errors from other modes might highlight the
actual buffer.

** Flycheck
This is the standard Spacemacs way of syntax checking, and it's also the most
elaborate. You need to install the syntax-checking layer first, which will bring flycheck. Please read the
layer's [[https://github.com/syl20bnr/spacemacs/tree/develop/layers/+checkers/syntax-checking][documentation]] on how to interact with flycheck.

Flycheck has different Haskell checkers: =haskell-dante=, =haskell-ghc=, =haskell-stack-ghc= and
=haskell-hlint=. Normally it can detect the best one to use automatically, but
if it doesn't work, then you can change it with ~SPC e s~.

** HLint
[[https://github.com/ndmitchell/hlint][HLint]] is a linter for Haskell. It doesn't detect errors (as long as it can parse
the file) but bad coding style and code smell. The HLint checker is called
*after* the flycheck GHC checker.

HLint can be configured per project via .hlint.yaml (check Hlint docs for more details).

* FAQ
** Dante reports missing/hidden imports for test files
The cause might be that Dante is not loading appropriate packages for the test suite target, instead it is loading packages for the library.

Solution is to create =.dir-local.el= in the directory where the test suite (usually =test/= or =tests/=) is and to put the line =((haskell-mode . ((dante-target . "--test"))))= into it.
This tells Dante to use test suite target when working with test files.

** The REPL doesn't work
Usually =haskell-mode= is great at figuring out which interactive process to
bring up. But if you are experiencing problems with it, then you can help
=haskell-mode= by setting =haskell-process-type= as in following code:

#+BEGIN_SRC emacs-lisp
  (setq-default dotspacemacs-configuration-layers
    '((haskell :variables haskell-process-type 'stack-ghci)))
#+END_SRC

Available options are:
- ghci
- cabal-repl
- cabal-new-repl
- cabal-dev
- cabal-ghci
- stack-ghci

** The REPL is stuck
Make sure that there's a space between the REPL's =λ>= prompt and the cursor.
When there is no space, then the REPL will behave as if it's stuck. Usually,
when you enter normal state, the cursor moves backwards by one character, so there
is no required space when you switch to insert mode. There is a possible
workaround - just add the following snippet to your =dotspacemacs/user-config=
function:

#+BEGIN_SRC emacs-lisp
  (when (configuration-layer/layer-used-p 'haskell)
    (add-hook 'haskell-interactive-mode-hook
              (lambda ()
                (setq-local evil-move-cursor-back nil))))
#+END_SRC

It makes the cursor stay in the right place in the REPL buffer when you enter
normal state. Which in most cases helps you to avoid the problem with 'stuck'
REPL.

Also, some users might want to start the REPL in insert mode. This is done by
placing the following snippet in your =dotspacemacs/user-config= function:

#+BEGIN_SRC emacs-lisp
  (when (configuration-layer/layer-used-p 'haskell)
      (defadvice haskell-interactive-switch (after spacemacs/haskell-interactive-switch-advice activate)
        (when (eq dotspacemacs-editing-style 'vim)
          (call-interactively 'evil-insert))))
#+END_SRC

** Indentation doesn't reset when pressing return after an empty line
This is the intended behavior in =haskell-indentation-mode=. If you want to
reset the indentation when pressing return after an empty line, add the
following snippet into your =dotspacemacs/user-config= function.

#+BEGIN_SRC emacs-lisp
  (defun haskell-indentation-advice ()
    (when (and (< 1 (line-number-at-pos))
               (save-excursion
                 (forward-line -1)
                 (string= "" (s-trim (buffer-substring (line-beginning-position) (line-end-position))))))
      (delete-region (line-beginning-position) (point))))

  (advice-add 'haskell-indentation-newline-and-indent
              :after 'haskell-indentation-advice)
#+END_SRC

** Flycheck displays HLint warnings but not errors
The HLint checker is called *after* the normal flycheck checker, even if the
checker fails. Check the [[#flycheck-doesnt-work][Flycheck doesn't work]] section.

** HLint fails with parse error
If HLint is not correctly configured (e.g. does not load some extensions that you are using in your project) it might fail while parsing the file.

Check [[https://github.com/ndmitchell/hlint][HLint]] docs for more details.

** I can see highlighted errors but they don't appear in the error list
The error list is only set by flycheck. You are probably seeing errors
highlighted by haskell-mode. Check the [[#flycheck-doesnt-work][Flycheck doesn't work]] section.

** Flycheck doesn't work
You can use the =flycheck-compile= command to check what's wrong with flycheck.
This will show you the exact command line that's used, and its output.

If you are using =stack=, check the [[#flycheck-doesnt-work-with-stack][Flycheck doesn't work with =stack=]] section.

** Flycheck doesn't work with =stack=
First check that flycheck uses the correct checker, and all the paths are
properly configured using =flycheck-verify-setup= (~SPC e v~). You can force the
checker with =flycheck-select-checker= (~SPC e s~) to ensure that it uses
=haskell-stack-ghc=. If it still doesn't work, then it could be one of the
following problems:
- The =stack= build directory is wrong
- The project root is not set properly

*** The =stack= build directory is wrong
The path to the build directory, which contains some generated files, is
normally under =.stack-work/install/<os>/Cabal-<version>/build=.

However the version of the cabal library that's used by =stack= to generate the
directory name is not the version of the cabal library that's installed by
=stack= but rather the version of cabal that's associated to the GHC version.
This error can happen after upgrading cabal or cabal-install. To check if this
is the problem, compare the path name of the build path that's used by flycheck
using =flycheck-compile= and compare it to the actual path in the =.stack-work=
directory. If they are different, then you'll need to reinstall ghc using the
command =stack setup --upgrade-cabal=.

*** The Project root directory is not set properly
Flycheck launches the GHC command, not from the project root directory, but from
the directory of the file that's being checked. This is normally not a problem,
as all the paths are set properly, however it could be a problem if some
template Haskell functions use relative paths (e.g. in Yesod scaffolded
projects).

Until it's fixed in flycheck, the workaround is to wrap the =stack= command in
order to run all subcommands from the project's root directory. You can do so
with the following script:

#+BEGIN_SRC bash
  #!/bin/bash
  cd `stack path --project-root`
  stack $*
#+END_SRC

Make sure you set =flycheck-haskell-stack-ghc-executable= to this script.

** haskell-mode commands don't work
Some (most) of the haskell-mode commands only work when haskell-mode is in
interactive mode, i.e. has an interactive session associated with it. Load it
using ~SPC m s b~.